PC Gamer's 2025 Top 100 list has conspicuous omissions, resonating with strategy and RPG fans. Several acclaimed games were excluded from the list, sparking debate among editors. The publication, well-known for its rigorous selection process, has left out titles cherished for their narrative depth and gameplay innovation.
Key Omissions from 2025 List
- Alpha Protocol (2010): Known for its reactive RPG elements, compelling spy-thriller plot, and intricate choice mechanics.
- Civilization VI (2016): A grand-strategy staple offering accessible city-building and historical exploration.
- Monster Train 2 (2025): Praised for enhancing card-based strategy with replayable, strategic gameplay.
- Warhammer: Vermintide 2: A co-op action-hit with strong DLC support and immersive melee combat.
- The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim (2011): Once a widely accessible RPG, now considered aged despite mods.
- Final Fantasy XIV (2013): An MMORPG lauded for its narrative but criticized for pacing.
Impact on Gaming Community
The omission of these titles is likely to stir up reactions among dedicated fans and critics. Alpha Protocol, with its focus on storytelling, and Civilization VI, a deep strategy game, have long-standing fanbases. Meanwhile, newer entries like Monster Train 2 showcased evolving mechanics that resonated with card game enthusiasts.
The exclusion of Skyrim and Final Fantasy XIV highlights the challenge of balancing legacy with innovation. For gamers, these omissions may influence perceptions of game longevity and criteria for top-tier selections in future rankings.
