PC Gamer has announced its top review scores for 2025, showcasing games that stood out according to individual reviewers' assessments. The list notably omits several contenders for Game of the Year, such as Nightreign, Battlefield 6, Europa Universalis 5, and Arc Raiders, which all received good but not exceptional scores.
Scoring Criteria and Standouts
To achieve a high review score from PC Gamer, a game must not only perform well but also inspire a strong personal endorsement from the reviewer. The publication stresses that scores are subjective, reflecting individual enthusiasm rather than a consensus. Games must score at least 89% to be included among the year's best.
Among those listed, Silksong, Halls of Torment, and Silent Hill f were particular highlights, achieving impressive scores of up to 94%. Despite successful entries, PC Gamer reports an overarching sense of quiet competence among games this year.
Exclusions and Scores
Despite favorable reception, games like Clair Obscur and others did not quite reach the top tier, as this year emphasized excelling in fundamentals over innovation. PC Gamer's scores included:
- 89% for a roguelike praised for its engaging dungeon dives.
- 90% for creative mixes, such as Halls of Torment.
- 91% for an extraordinary deckbuilder sequel.
- 94% for a praised strategy adventure and a city council title.
These reviews highlight the balance between visionary concepts and technical execution, showing that mastery of basics continues to be essential.
