Retired Microsoft engineer Dave Plummer has criticized Windows 11 for prioritizing Microsoft services over user experience.
Microsoft's Shifts and Strategies
According to Plummer, Windows 11 pushes users into Microsoft's ecosystem: Microsoft 365, OneDrive, and Edge (browser) are prominently recommended. This began with Windows 10's move to Windows-as-a-service, focusing on cloud revenue. Windows 11 intensified this with more strict requirements and default-promoted content.
- Microsoft 365 apps promoted in Start menu.
- OneDrive sign-ups prompted in Settings.
- Edge integrated heavily with Bing and other services.
Impact on Power Users
Plummer argues Windows functions more as a sales channel than a neutral OS. He suggests concrete fixes: a Pro Mode switch, disabling web search by default, and a 'privacy ledger' for telemetry. Plummer also calls for account setup transparency and update clarity.
Future Prospects and Concerns
Plummer is skeptical about Microsoft addressing these concerns due to the need for a different product approach. Despite this, he praises Windows’ robust kernel and development tools. He concludes Windows excels fundamentally, but notes issues arise when product decisions overlook user needs.
